Menu

THEOPHRASTUS

Reviewed by Herb Levy

THEOPHRASTUS (Mayfair Games; 2-5 players, Ages 9 through Adult; 30-45 minutes; $25)

 

As recounted in the rulebook, Theophrastus von Bombast der Hohenheim was a renowned physician (“considered by many to be the father of ‘modern medicine'”), occultist and alchemist who lived back in the 16th Century, a contemporary and equal of Nicholas Copernicus, Martin Luther and Leonardo da Vinci. Obviously, such a stellar figure required help in his work. In Theophrastus, the new card game devised by P.R. Chase, players compete to win the envious position of apprentice to the great Theophrastus. But such a reward does not come easy. You have to prove your skill and worthiness. That means you will have to compete to duplicate (or, at least, come as close as possible to duplicating) the mysterious formulae of the great alchemist.

Theophrastus is a card game that comes boxed with 27 Experiment parchments, 5 Player Research Guides, 120 Ingredient Cards, a Theophrastus Marker (a mortar and pestle) and 16 page rulebook.Theophras

Each player begins with a Player Research Guide. These guides (4″x7″ cardboard cards) serve both as player aids (as to what actions may be taken and their respective costs) and as the area where a player’s formula will be constructed. The 27 Experiment “parchments” (another set of 4″x7″ cards) are separated into A, B and C piles (as noted on the parchments). One of the A parchments is randomly drawn and placed in the center of the playing area. This will be the formula the players will attempt to duplicate this round. On the left side of the Experiment parchment is an explanation of the particular formula. (Nice for “atmosphere” but not really necessary for the game.) The key part of the parchment is located on the right hand side which is divided into three sections for the three types of Reagents in the game: Metals (red), Elements (blue) and Essentials (yellow). To paraphrase Humphrey Bogart, “This is the stuff that formulas are made of”.

Each player’s guide contains the same three boxes – but those boxes are empty. Since you are only a prospective apprentice, Theophrastus gives you clues to the composition of the formula right on the Experiment parchment. You may see a particular metal listed (such as Copper). That tells you that Copper is DEFINITELY part of the formula and, to make the most of your effort, Copper should be included in YOUR formula. Sometimes, a box will be less specific. For example, “Any 3” in the Elements box means that any 3 blue Elements will be satisfactory. (But, again, the closer you get to the actual elements used by Theophrastus, the more credit you receive.) In some cases, a box might prohibit use of a substance by noting something like “any 3 Essentials but NOT Mercury”. Using Mercury in your formula under those circumstances would get you nothing! Now, you know SOME of what goes into the formula. The remainder you have to divine or discover for yourself.

The Ingredient Cards are shuffled and divided into five approximately equal piles. Each player takes one card from the top of each of the five stacks to create a starting hand of five Ingredient Cards. Three types of Ingredient Cards appear in the game: Normal Reagents, Special Ingredients, and Philosophers’ Stones. The Normal Reagents are the basic “tools of the trade”, specifying the type of ingredient along with a point total (ranging from 2 to 6 points). There are Special Ingredients for each type of Reagent: Lodestone (for Metals), Ether (for Elements) and Aqua Fortis (for Essentials). All are worth 3 points when scoring and these cards can be exchanged (for lesser valued substances) or act as “Wild Cards” and match ANY similar colored substance in the Experiment during the Scoring Round. Philosophers’ Stone Cards are the most powerful cards in the game. Their effects can result in changing one ingredient into another, invalidating an ingredient in play, plucking a card from another player’s hand and more! (Once used, Philosopher Stone cards are discarded.)

The oldest player gets the Theophrastus marker making him the “starting” player. As starting player, he draws a card and then MUST advance Theophrastus’ formula by playing any card from his hand onto the Experiment parchment, FACE DOWN, that fills a requirement of that formula. (If unable to advance the formula, the player to his left becomes the starting player immediately.) Now, starting with the player to the left of the starting player, each player in the game performs a set of actions.Theoback

On his turn, a player draws a card. At that point, he has 3 Action Points (AP) to use. He may draw another card (1 AP), look through any of the five stacks of Ingredient cards and take one of them (3 AP), place a card, FACE UP, onto his own experiment (1 AP), place a card, FACE DOWN, onto his own experiment (2 AP), play a card, FACE DOWN, onto Theophrastus’ experiment (3 AP), play any Special Card (1 AP), play a Philosopher’s Stone card (1 AP), flip over any face down card (2 AP) or look at any face down card in the playing area but keep it face down (3 AP). A player may flip over any of his own cards for free. A player may never end a turn with more than five cards in his hand. (If he has more than five, the excess must be discarded and returned to the bottom of one or more of the Ingredient piles.) The starting player, in taking his own player turn, completes the set of player turns (called a Research Round). The Theophrastus marker is shifted to the left and a new set of Research Rounds begins. Rounds continue until Theophrastus’s formula is completed, triggering scoring.

Immediately upon placing the last card completing the Theophrastus’ Experiment (whether by the starting player or by another player using all 3 of his Action Points for the turn), play stops and the “Scoring Round” starts.

Each player, beginning with the player to the left of the starting player, is allowed to take one last action. No action taken may cost more than 1 AP and reagents in the Theophrastus’ Experiment may not be altered (although reagents in any player’s experiment may be changed). Once all players have done their final action, all face down cards are exposed and scores are calculated.

Cards in a player’s formula are compared to those found in Theophrastus’ formula. For every card that matches a card in the Experiment (Copper to Copper, for example), a player scores the full point value of the card. Ingredients that do NOT match those in the Experiment (e.g. you have Copper but the formula uses Lead) only score 1 point. Forbidden ingredients found in your formula score no points at all. Once scores are tallied, all players replenish their hands to five cards (if necessary). The remaining Ingredient cards (those unused in the first contest and those used and discarded) are shuffled together and divided into five stacks (as before). Now, a second Experiment is randomly selected from the B stack of formulae and the next contest commences, followed by a final contest using a formula from stack C. After all potential apprentices have finished the last competition, point totals for all three contests are added. The player who has amassed the most total points wins the coveted position of apprentice to Theophrastus (and wins the game)!

Theophrastus has a lot of nice touches to it. The limited intelligence afforded to players by knowing some of the reagents in the formula and the limited Actions possible each turn force tough decisions. Should you keep your reagents secret (at a cost of 2 AP per play) or play them open (at only 1 AP)? This is a tough choice since reagents are vulnerable to Wild Cards and Philosophers Stone Cards ONLY when face up! Should you expose a face down reagent in Theophrastus’ formula (so all players know what’s there) or spend all of your AP that turn to see it and then return it face down? Having the starting player go last in his player turn and the ability to end a round by using your 3 AP to advance the formula works well as a balancing mechanism so that the starting player does not get an unfair advantage. The limited ability to make one last move (at a cost of 1 AP) during the Scoring Round gives you some “wriggle room” to adjust your formula or conjure one last “dirty trick” to salvage your score (or whittle down the opposition). As you gain experience and move from Experiments A to B to C, more reagents are needed, leaving you more vulnerable to attack from your fellow would-be apprentices. On the other hand, there are a few improvements that we’d strongly recommend.

The Player Research Guides and Experiment parchments should have been made bigger, at least 5″x8″. As they are, the boxes for the reagents are SMALLER than the dimensions of the cards. Equal sized boxes would have been so much more aesthetically pleasing. Larger Guides and Experiment cards would easily fit into the box. In this case, size does matter. More troubling is that a key feature of the game is obscured in the otherwise clear rules.

A key mechanism in the game is advancing Theophrastus’ formula. At first glance, it appears that, even if an ingredient is named on the card, a card for that ingredient must still be played onto the formula. Wrong! When the formula states, for example, that Mercury is needed, then it is a given that Mercury is present and a Mercury card is considered to be present already! In our first session with the game, we missed this and the game play suffered terribly. The conclusion is simple: a game plays better with the right rules. In a rulebook that displays clarity on other points, this handling of limited intelligence should have been made crystal clear. It wasn’t. Even the examples of scoring tend to reinforce this misconception. An errata sheet should definitely be included in the next printing.

Theophrastus is a card game that will test your acumen in second guessing your opponents in pursuing mystical, magical formulae. While alchemists were known for their failed attempts at turning lead into gold, Theophrastus succeeds in magically transmuting a deck of cards cards into a pleasurable game. This is a worthy first effort from P.R. Chase, a designer we’d like to see more from in the future.- – – – – – Herb Levy


 

Have feedback? We’d love to hear from you.


Summer 2002 GA Report Articles

 

Reviewed by Herb Levy 1313 Dead End Drive (Parker Brothers, 2 to 4 players, about 1 hour; $19.99) We've seen vintage mystery conundrums served up in game form before: the dead body in the mansion, murder on a train and the case of the wealthy relative suddenly dying and leaving fabulous wealth to those who survive. Several years ago, the latter scenario was the theme ...
Read More
Reviewed by Greg J. Schloesser DSCHUNKE (Queen Games; 3-5 players, 1-1½ hours; about $40) I am always hesitant to take chances on games "sight unseen", but sometimes the lure of newly released games proves to be just too much. When putting together a recent game order from Germany, most of the newer Nürnberg releases were not yet available. One exception was Dschunke from Michael Schacht, ...
Read More
SPOILS The jury has returned with its verdict. Villa Paletti has won this year's coveted Spiel des Jahres (German Game of the Year) award. With the SdJ sticker on the box, Villa Paletti can expect to earn more profits for the good people at Zoch. Congratulations are in order. To the victor, goes the spoils. And yet... Back in the old days before I even ...
Read More
[Every once in a while, a game arrives on the scene that seems to take on a life of its own. Such a game is Santa Fe, an Alan Moon design that originally appeared on his own label, White Wind Games. The game was a critical success but a limited edition. With the passage of years, the stature of the game has grown as ...
Read More
K-BAN'S KORNER Santa Fe Rails & Clippers Of all the limited edition (numbered print run of 1200) White Wind Games, Santa Fe was my favorite – yes, even compared with Elfenroads (Summer 1993 GA REPORT). It’s hard to believe that 10 years have flown by since Alan R. Moon paid homage to Wolfgang Kramer’s Wildlife Adventure (later updated by Herr Kramer to Expedition). Why shouldn’t ...
Read More
K-BAN'S KORNER TransAmerica (Winning Moves/Rio Grande Games, 2 to 6 players, 30 minutes; $24.95) Railroad games are usually both long and complex. Not so for TransAmerica by Franz-Benno Delonge, a railroad themed connection game for those with short attention spans and little tolerance for learning new rules. A new game that you can be playing in a couple of minutes and takes 5-10 minutes per ...
Read More
Reviewed by Herb Levy STARSHIP CATAN (Mayfair Games/Kosmos, 2 players, about 1 hour; $30) The Settlers of Catan (featured back in the Fall 1996 GA REPORT) has become a cottage industry for its creator, Klaus Teuber, as well as its publishers, Kosmos (in Europe) and Mayfair Games (here in the United States). It has spawned numerous variations including The Settlers of Nuremberg, shifting the setting ...
Read More
Reviewed by Herb Levy THEOPHRASTUS (Mayfair Games; 2-5 players, Ages 9 through Adult; 30-45 minutes; $25) As recounted in the rulebook, Theophrastus von Bombast der Hohenheim was a renowned physician ("considered by many to be the father of 'modern medicine'"), occultist and alchemist who lived back in the 16th Century, a contemporary and equal of Nicholas Copernicus, Martin Luther and Leonardo da Vinci. Obviously, such ...
Read More
Reviewed by Dave Rapp TIN SOLDIERS (R&R Games, 3 to 4 players, less than an hour; $9.99) Tin Soldiers, from R& R Games, is great little trick-taking game created by Al Newman with enough new twists to charm even the most jaded card playing gamer. Before I begin describing the game, I do think it’s fair to warn the reader that I am listed in ...
Read More

If you enjoy games, then Gamers Alliance is right for you!