[It’s been awhile since we revisited great games from the past that have departed from the shelves of the marketplace. In past installments of our Game Classics series, we have featured an incredible assortment of brilliant designs: Astron, Bantu, Broker, Can’t Stop, Daytona 500, Focus, Holiday, Kimbo, Mr. President, Ploy, Rich Uncle, Square Mile, Stock Market Game (by Gabriel), Summit, Troque/Troke, Trump: the Game (1989) and Wildcatter. In this issue, we go on a mission: to rescue a princess from powerful wizards in Spellmaker.]

Reviewed by Herb Levy

SPELLMAKER (GameTime Games, 1978, 2, 3 or 4 players, ages 8 and up, 45 minutes to 3 hours; out of print)


Heritage Models, a company devoted to wargaming, launched a series of lighter games in the mid 1970s. The line included a bunch of very interesting titles including Quest (medieval knights), Grand Imperialism (colonization), Sopwith (World War I air combat), Star Fighter (space combat) and Strange New Worlds (space colonization). While all of these games had something to offer, one of them in particular stands out – their game of wizards and enchantments: Spellmaker.spellmaker1

Spellmaker came in a big square box that held a mounted mapboard, four sets of counters, a deck of 108 spell cards and only four pages of rules. The uncredited designer of the game was Eric Solomon, best known for Conspiracy (aka The Sigma File) and Black Box. In Spellmaker, Solomon turned his attention to fantasy and magic as each player became a powerful wizard whose goal was to find the princess of the realm and safely transport her back to his castle.

The large board shows the, mostly impassable, enchanted land. On each of the four corners is a castle of a wizard (in red, blue, black or yellow). Linking the four castles is a crisscross of paths dotted with clearings. All clearings, called “domains”, are marked by cottages, villages and symbols. Larger clearings (called “magic domains”) are also named. The princess counter begins in the center of the board.

Each player receives circular counters in their color in five varieties (from strongest to weakest): giants, princes, dwarves, frogs and toadstools. The spell cards are shuffled and players dealt a starting hand of 4 cards (with 4 players), or 5 cards (with 3) or 6 cards (with 2). The remaining cards become a draw deck. Now, players place one of each type of their counters, in order, one at a time, on any domain on the board. At the start, only one piece may inhabit any one domain. Play begins with the player placing the last counter going first.

Combat is the first action to be resolved and it’s done very simply and cleanly. Pieces of the active player remove ALL pieces of lesser strength in an area occupied by forces of that player. For example, giants remove all other pieces (except other giants) but dwarves can only remove frogs and toadstools. Toadstools, however, are not defenseless. They are poisonous and will remove any giants caught in their area! Removal is at the discretion of the active player as pieces do NOT have to be removed. Now, the player is faced with the choice of either moving OR casting a spell.spellmaker2

On turn, a player may move ONE of his pieces. All pieces (except the toadstool which remains rooted where it is placed) are allowed to move to an adjacent domain. If that piece is moving from a domain that the princess occupies, that piece may take the princess along for the ride! Of course, should another piece occupy that space, that new piece may move the princess, quite likely in a totally different direction, on that player’s turn!

Instead of moving, a player may cast ONE spell, done by playing a card (or cards) from his hand. The 108 card spell deck consists of 20 cards in each of the four colors (four cards depicting each of the 5 characters), 10 “Wild” cards (two each of the 5 characters valid for use with any color) and 18 Null cards. By playing the right set of cards, counters can be changed to different characters, e.g. a red dwarf may morph into a red giant. (There is a restriction here. A player may have no more than three of the same type of his pieces on the board at any one time.) A character card played with a Null card removes that piece from the board or, alternatively, places a new counter in a magic domain. Multiple cards of the same character allow that character to travel “magically” from magic domain to magic domain, effectively doubling (or even quadrupling) a counter’s movement. Wizards can play defense too. They can always cancel a spell, immediately out of turn, by playing the same number of Null cards as was used in an opponent’s spell. But the use of spells has limitations. They may only be cast on characters in a magic domain.spellmakerboxspellmakerbox

Players are limited to their starting hand size UNLESS they manage to escort the princess to the magic domain which lies just outside each of their castles. Each time that happens, the hand limit of that wizard increases by 1. Since spell casting is the engine that runs this machine, hand size is of paramount importance.

The first wizard to successfully bring the princess back to his castle wins!

Spellmaker had all the makings of a classic – until the folks at Heritage got their hands on it! As too often happens, the vision of the designer is blurred in the finished product. To speed up play, Heritage contributed two ideas. The good one was to make the wizard castles magic domains for the purpose of moving the princess, making “princess transport” easier. The bad idea was to expand the game’s original number of cards (62) to a much larger 108. The idea was that more cards made for more action. The reality was that more cards made it more difficult to draw the cards you needed, made Null cards uncommon leading to players hoarding them for the “right moment” and, because of the larger deck, led to less reshuffling so needed cards appeared less often. This led to an endgame that could drag on much too long. (Note the three hour possible game time above!)

Designer Solomon has offered two excellent suggestions for speeding up and improving the game with which we concur. First, restore the original game deck, easy enough to do by pruning the existing deck until you’re left with 62 cards: two cards in each color for each of the five creatures plus 10 Wild cards (2 for each creature) plus 12 Null cards. Now cards will continually be recycled and the ever helpful Null cards will appear more frequently. Second, modify the game turn to allow players to move AND play a spell each turn. The result? Cards will fly across the table as spells are cast and characters moved, bringing the game to an exciting conclusion in a reasonable time.

Spellmaker is an intriguing game of magical spells. By implementing the modest modifications suggested by the designer, Spellmaker magically transforms itself into an engaging game of enchantment that reaches deserved classic game status. – – – – – – – – – – – – – Herb Levy


Have feedback? We’d love to hear from you.

Winter 2005 GA Report Articles


Reviewed by Herb Levy (Australian Design Group, 2-7 players, ages 7 and up, 7 hours but variable depending on scenario; $70) World history has often been mirrored in the games we play with the rise and fall of civilizations being the focus. But covering history on a grand scale is a daunting task challenging the most adept game designers. There have been notable attempts over ...
Read More
Reviewed by Frank Branham (Kosmos/Rio Grande, 3-6 Players, 60 Minutes; $37.95) "When you turn one of these up, do you get Shirley MacLaine?" - Steven Carlberg, first time Around the World in 80 Days player. The Kosmos box for Around the World in 80 Days is a little confusing as the little blurb right up at the top shows clearly that the game was designed ...
Read More
Reviewed by Herb Levy (Outset Media, 2-6 players, ages 12 and up, about 60 minutes; $29.99) One of the crimes of modern times is the theft of archeological treasures. In Artifact, you do something about it as part of an Artifact Recovery Team, winging your way around the world to recover these stolen goods. Artifact comes boxed with a mounted board depicting the world bordered ...
Read More
Reviewed by Herb Levy (Face to Face Games, 3-5 players, ages 10 and up, 30+ minutes; $22.95) There's something about the American Wild West that fascinates Europeans and the American west takes center stage in Boomtown, the new collaboration from Bruno Cathala and Bruno Faidutti. The premise of the game is simple: players are prospectors searching for gold during the gold rush, competing for mine ...
Read More
Reviewed by Herb Levy (Out-of-the-Box GAMES, 3- 6 players, ages 8 and up; 20-30 minutes; $12.99) Some games dare you to risk it all! This generally brings to mind wargames (when you commit your troops in a last ditch attempt to turn the tide of battle) or casino gambling (when you hope and pray that the right card or roulette number comes up). Yet, the ...
Read More
[Al Newman has had a varied career as a game designer since he entered this arena in 1973. His work has appeared in early issues of GAMES Magazine, for example, and his considerable design credits include Super 3 (Milton Bradley), Babuschka (Ravensburger), Match 3 (Nathan), Wacky Wizard (Western) as well as many early computer designs such as Domination (which won the first First prize ever ...
Read More
The Thirteen Club There seems to be a club for every interest. Stamps, coins, politics, you name it; the list goes on forever. Why should games be any different? If you're reading this, you're in the club, for you share an interest in games with the rest of us. And, if you're reading this, you're also in another club: The Thirteen Club. Thirteen and superstitions ...
Read More
(Sometimes games that have gone out of print return to entertain a new set of game players. Sometimes, these games are "serious" simulations. But, more often than not, they are simply enjoyable games, easy for all ages to enjoy. This is what has happened with Cloud 9, a "lighter than air" diversion that has been given new life with a new edition from Out of ...
Read More
[It's been awhile since we revisited great games from the past that have departed from the shelves of the marketplace. In past installments of our Game Classics series, we have featured an incredible assortment of brilliant designs: Astron, Bantu, Broker, Can't Stop, Daytona 500, Focus, Holiday, Kimbo, Mr. President, Ploy, Rich Uncle, Square Mile, Stock Market Game (by Gabriel), Summit, Troque/Troke, Trump: the Game (1989) ...
Read More
Reviewed by Herb Levy (Hanser/Rio Grande Games; 3-4 players, ages 12 and up, 60 minutes; $37.95) The festive atmosphere of Oktoberfest, of beer gardens and pretty waitresses, has combined with the business side of breweries in Goldbräu, the brainchild of Franz-Benno Delonge, best known for his Transamerica (featured in the Summer 2002 GA REPORT). Goldbräu comes with a mounted gameboard, 70 cards consisting of 24 ...
Read More
Reviewed by Herb Levy (Mind the Move, 2-5 players, ages 10 and up, about 60 minutes; about $30) Part of the thrill of tearing the shrink off new games is seeing if a gem lurks underneath. Such a thrill happened with Oltremare, one of the unexpected treats of this year's Essen Game Fair. Oltremare: Merchants of Venice, designed by Emanuelle Ornella, is one of those ...
Read More
Reviewed by Herb Levy (R&D Games, 2-4 players, ages 9 and up, about 2 hours; about $100) Inspiration can come from many sources - even television! The evidence? It seems that a BBC television documentary on coral reefs and the lifestyles of the creatures inhabiting them was the inspiration for Reef Encounter, the latest offering from Richard Breese (whose Keythedral was featured last issue). Reef ...
Read More
Reviewed by Mark Delano (Ystari Games, 3-4 players, ages 12 and up, about 90 minutes; about $50) Sometimes new games are eagerly anticipated months before their release. Others, like Ystari Game's Ys, seem to appear out of nowhere. Created by otherwise unknown designer Cyril Demaegd, it became one of the more popular new games at Essen this October. What interested me was not the theme, ...
Read More