Reviewed by Greg. J. Schloesser

(Hans im Glück/Rio Grande Games; 2-4 players, ages 12 and up, 1 hour; $49.99)


What’s that old cliché? Something like: “Keep riding the horse that brought you!” I guess designer Klaus-Jurgen Wrede and Hans im Glück have found their horse, and its name is Carcassonne (Summer 2001 GA REPORT). Since the release of the original a few years back, we have seen a steady stream of expansions and spin-offs. The latest “stand alone” game in the series is Carcassonne: The City.

When I first heard about the game I decided to not purchase it. It’s not that I dislike Carcassonne. Quite the contrary. However, just how many variations of the same game does anyone really need in their collection. I already own Carcassonne, Hunters & Gatherers, The Castle and Ark of the Covenant, as well as two expansions. That’s enough, thank you. So, I didn’t even give the game a glimpse at the Essen show.

As fate would have it, the reports that began filtering in following the show were praising The City as one of the best and most strategic in the series. So, in spite of my “enough is enough” mindset, I finally yielded to the temptation and purchased a copy. Much to my delight, I found myself in complete agreement with the sentiments expressed in these reports. This version of Carcassonne is the most strategic of the lot and is quite fun. In addition, it is certainly the most visually appealing, with wooden walls and towers resulting in an impressive spectacle as the game progresses. Ultimately, it may even relegate some of its ancestors to the Bayou Bazaar.

Don’t get me wrong … this is Carcassonne. The heart of the system remains intact. Players alternate selecting and placing a tile into the city, causing the board to expand as the game progresses. After placing a tile, players must decide whether or not to place a “follower”, those cute wooden pieces known affectionately to gamers as “meeples”. Players score points when certain board features are completed, while others score at the end of the game. Most points wins.

However, there are significant differences. Gone are the construction of small and large cities, and Carcassonnecityboxfields. In their place we have residential areas and markets, as well as public and historical buildings. Only road segments need to properly align on adjacent tiles. The remaining tile features can abut without matching, a mechanism which is similar to that used in The Castle, the Carcassonne 2-player version. This actually gives players more placement options and more decisions, which is a very good addition.

Markets wind their way throughout the town and can contain up to three different types of markets: fish, grain and livestock. When a market is completely surrounded either by walls or residential areas, it scores 1 point for each tile contained in the market multiplied by the number of different markets present. For example, a market consisting of four tile segments and containing both a fish and grain market will score 8 points (4 x 2 = 8).

Residential areas do not score until the end of the game, and will earn two points for each different market area that borders it. Roads also score a bit differently, scoring 1 point per tile if the road is three or less tile segments in length, and two points for tile if it longer than three segments. In the case of roads and markets, followers are returned to the owning player immediately after the scoring, while followers in residential areas will remain in place until the end of the game.

Another major difference is that players may no longer complete a feature that does not contain a follower, and subsequently place a follower in order to score quick points. This was a major tactic used in the other versions of Carcassonne, so it takes a bit getting used to this change. However, it does force players into longer-term strategies, which does add some additional depth to the game.

The most visible change, however, is the addition of the walls and towers. Before the game begins, the 90 tiles are separated into three stacks of 35, 30, and 20 tiles. When the first scoring is triggered while the second stack of tiles is in use, players will begin placing walls to ring the burgeoning city. Thereafter, each time a scoring is triggered, each player places one segment of the wall adjacent to a previously placed wall. They then have the option of placing a follower as a guard atop the wall piece. These guards cannot be placed if there is a guard on a wall segment directly across from the newly placed wall and there is an uninterrupted line of tiles between the two wall segments.carcassthecity

So why place a guard on a wall? At game end, each guard will score for the row of tiles emanating from it. Each public building depicted on the tiles will score two points, while each historical building, denoted by an incredibly tiny banner listing the name of the building, scores three points. These points can be significant, a harsh fact I learned at the conclusion of my first game. Often, these points can rise to double digits, so the wise player will conserve some of his precious few followers to take advantage of guard opportunities.

After each player has had the opportunity to play a wall segment and guard, the player who triggered the scoring also has the opportunity to place one of his three towers at either end of the current wall. Towers earn one point for each wall segment between it and the nearest existing tower along the wall. Since a player only possesses three towers, the urge is to conserve them. However, players usually will only have a handful of opportunities to place them, so being too cautious will likely cost the player valuable points.

Once the players begin placing tiles from the third stack, further scorings will result in each player placing two wall segments. Since two of the possible game-end conditions is having the entire city either enclosed by walls or by having the two ends of the walls reach within 5 segments of each other, this creates an increased sense of urgency in the players as they rush to close roads and markets and place their guards and towers.

Once the game ends, any followers located on unfinished roads and markets are removed and do not score points. Thus, players are wise to attempt to complete these areas prior to the game’s conclusion. Merchants and guards are then scored as described, and the player with the most points is declared ruler of Carcassonne.

There are some significant choices to be made during the course of the game, more than what is present in the original version of the game. Further, each player only possesses 7 followers, so players do not have the luxury of placing one on each turn. This, too, adds some tough choices to the proceedings, especially in regards to the residential areas. One had best be confident that the points earned from a residential area is worth the cost of tying down one or more of your followers for the entire game.

Wall placement also presents players with tough choices. Often, players are fearful of triggering a scoring, as the ensuing wall placement phase may give an opponent the opportunity to place a wall and guard in a location that will yield copious amounts of points. One of our games saw everyone actively attempting to avoid triggering a scoring lest their opponents benefit from a lucrative wall and guard placement. The game was quite tense … and fulfilling.

A further feature of the game is its appearance; it is aesthetically beautiful. The artwork is similar to that found in previous Carcassonne titles, but the addition of the walls, towers and game make for a truly eye-catching construction. Play this one on a table in a public place and you are sure to attract some curious onlookers.

My determination to not add another Carcassonne variation to my collection nearly prevented me from enjoying what is quite likely the best of the series. I’m happy I was convinced to second-guess myself! – – – – – – – Greg J. Schloesser


Have feedback? We’d love to hear from you.

Spring 2005 GA Report Articles


Reviewed by Frank Branham (Splotter Spellen, 2-4 players, ages 14 and up, 3-4 hours; about $130) I just spent $130.00 on a game. This is not even close to the first time this has happened for me, any miniatures game, collectible game, or mega-deluxe wooden game costs. Antiquity, however, has none of this -- it is pretty much die-cut cardboard. A LOT of diecut cardboard ...
Read More
Reviewed by Herb Levy (Eagle Games/Rebel Forge, 2-6 players, ages 12 to adult, 3-4 hours; $49.99) Just when New York is enjoying hard earned accolades as the safest large city in the United States (a trend, as a New Yorker, I hope to see continue), Eagle Games, teaming up with the design team at Rebel Forge, releases a game with a totally different perception of ...
Read More
Reviewed by Herb Levy (Eagle Games/SDR Games, 3-6 players, ages 12 to adult, 30-60 minutes; $39.99) The Roaring 20s didn't get its name by accident. It truly was a wild time in the United States, partly attributable to Prohibition. With liquor banned, the demand for the illegal elixir rose rapidly. As is so often the case, when the law-abiding part of society cannot or will ...
Read More
Reviewed by Greg. J. Schloesser (Hans im Glück/Rio Grande Games; 2-4 players, ages 12 and up, 1 hour; $49.99) What’s that old cliché? Something like: “Keep riding the horse that brought you!” I guess designer Klaus-Jurgen Wrede and Hans im Glück have found their horse, and its name is Carcassonne (Summer 2001 GA REPORT). Since the release of the original a few years back, we ...
Read More
Reviewed by Herb Levy (Winning Moves, 2 to 4 players, about 15 minutes, ages 8 to adult; about $10) To Conceal your secret code, Outguess your opponent, Deduce the solution and Amaze your foes is the object of Coda, the new code-breaking game from Winning Moves. Coda comes small boxed to hold its 26 numbered tiles - a set of 13 black andCoda a set ...
Read More
Reviewed by Herb Levy (Out of the Box Games, 2-4 players, ages 8 to adult, 20-30 minutes; $14.95) Back when dinosaurs roamed the earth and I was a kid discovering card games, I played a lot of something called Steal the Old Man's Bundle. This was a variant of Casino where players not only collected matching cards to make sets, they were able to swipe ...
Read More
The Shadow Knows "Who knows what evil lurks in the hearts of men? The Shadow knows!" Those words, uttered by several radio actors including the legendary Orson Welles, followed by mysterious, blood chilling laughter, heralded the beginning of a new adventure of The Shadow, famed crimefighter with the ability to cloud men's minds. During the 1930s and 40s, The Shadow was one of the top ...
Read More
Reviewed by Al Newman (Yuhodo, Inc., 2-5 players, ages 8 and up. about 30-60 minutes; about $25) Fairy Tale is a card game by Satoshi Nakamura that is for 2 to 5 players said to last up to an hour but will typically take less than a half-hour to play. The principal mechanic is identical to "Booster Draft" used in many Magic: The Gathering tournaments ...
Read More
(In this issue, we feature Ticket to Ride Europe, the sequel to Ticket to Ride, the acclaimed railroad game of laying track across the United States. TTR Europe bears some strong resemblances to its predecessor so we thought a quick look at the original game was in order. Here, from the Spring 2004 issue of Gamers Alliance Report, is our look at the 2004 ...
Read More
Reviewed by Herb Levy (Winning Moves Games, 2-4 players, ages 10 and up, 35-60 minutes; $7.95) Phil Orbanes has a game design resume about as broad as you can get. He designed the first wargame on Vietnam (Vietnam by Gamescience back in 1965), the brilliant business game Cartel (by Gamut of Games) as well as lighter fare such as the very successful Trumpet (International Games ...
Read More
[Sometimes an idea takes hold, enjoys success and spawns a deluge of imitations. This maxim holds true for all sorts of media, games included. Often, in the wake of a hit, a host of games sharing a similar theme will flood the market. In this issue of GA REPORT, "hit" takes on a whole new meaning as we've become immersed in a mob of games ...
Read More
Reviewed by Larry Levy (Kosmos/Rio Grande, 2 players, ages 10 and up, about 30 minutes, $22.95) Remember that commercial for peanut butter cups that aired a while back? The tag line was something like, “two great tastes in one candy!”. That was the kind of anticipation I felt when Jambo was announced. Not only was the game going to be part of one of my ...
Read More
Reviewed by Herb Levy (Gamewright, 2-8 players, ages 10 and up, about 20 minutes; $9.99) Originally released back in 1992 as Pirat and later reissued as Korsar, Loot is yet the third incarnation of Reiner Knizia's card game of plundering pirates. Loot comes in a small box containing a deck of 78 cards (consisting of merchant ships, pirate ships, pirate captains and an Admiral) and ...
Read More
Reviewed by Herb Levy (Playroom Entertainment, 2-4 players, ages 10 to adult, about 20 minutes; $9.95) One of the most prolific and successful game designers in today's marketplace is Maureen Hiron. Among her many successful designs are 77, Duo (both featured in the Winter 1995 GA REPORT) and Quadwrangle (Winter 1998 GA REPORT). One of her latest releases is a charming card game suitable for ...
Read More
Reviewed by Herb Levy (Warfrog, 2-7 players, ages 13 and up, 3-4 hours; $59.95) Struggle of Empires is the latest design from Martin Wallace, creator of such varied releases as Age of Steam (Winter 2003 GA REPORT) and Election USA (Fall 2004 GA REPORT) but the game bears a stronger resemblance to another of Wallace's works: Princes of the Renaissance (Winter 2004 GA REPORT). In ...
Read More
Reviewed by Herb Levy (Avalon Hill, 2-5 players, ages 10 and up, about 60 minutes; $45) The resurrected Avalon Hill has come up with several engaging titles in its relatively brief life. These include older classics such as Acquire (Spring 2000 GA REPORT) and new fare such as Battle Cry (Summer 2000 GA REPORT). In the first of the latest burst of releases, Avalon Hill ...
Read More
Reviewed by Herb Levy (Days of Wonder; 2-5 players, ages 8 and up, 30-60 minutes; $39.95) It's happened a million times. There's a hit, be it a TV show or a film, and the urge to continue that success proves overwhelming. So there are sequels. Rarely are the sequels as good as the original. A notable exception that comes to mind is The Godfather. That ...
Read More
by Mark Delano It is easy to denigrate categories of games that you rarely play. It is much harder to come up with a valid reason for this disdain. A little over a year ago I found I had developed an attitude toward two player games that was quite dismissive. The primary objection was based on the lack of shifting interactions between players you get ...
Read More

If you enjoy games, then Gamers Alliance is right for you!