Reviewed by: Joe Huber
(Asmodee Editions/Ystari, 4 players, ages 13 and up, 10 minutes; $39.99)
Every year, after Essen, I participate in a few gatherings to play through the new games. Over the course of a few weekends, I’ll typically end up playing 30 or more new games – most of which I’ll never come back to again. I really enjoy playing new (and new-to-me) games, but as a practical matter my usual expectation is to find a half dozen or so games I really enjoy from each new Essen crop.
This past year, I got to attend an additional post-Essen weekend, with just 3-5 gamers joining in to play almost nothing but new games. I played a total of 40 games in two and a half days – including 26 games I’d not played previously. And I hated all of them. Well, OK, no, I didn’t – or even close – but only one game struck me well enough to seek out a copy after even though I suspected that like most cooperative games, I didn’t need to own it. That game was Witness.
Witness is a cooperative deduction game – or, if you prefer, a cooperative logic puzzle – designed by Dominique Bodin and based upon (depending upon your favorite vernacular) The Telephone Game or Chinese Whispers. It’s a game for four players only, which always starts with a case, giving players some information about what they are trying to solve. Each person then reads their own case book, with some of the necessary information to solve the case, and the information is passed clockwise around the table. This passing of data occurs over four brief rounds. During each round, two of the players pass along all of the information they have to the next player. In the next round, the roles are reversed, and the listeners pass along their information instead. After four rounds (ideally resulting in all required data having passed around the table), players are finally allowed to take notes on the information they’ve heard; until then, it must be kept in memory. Finally, three questions are asked of everyone individually and, without consulting one another, every player must answer the questions. The number of questions answered correctly is added up, and a team score is generated.
About two months after I tried Witness, I had the opportunity to buy the copy I played and, in spite of my reservations, I decided to do so. And, much to my surprise, the game grew on me, quickly becoming a favorite – and so far my most played game of 2015.
This has not happened because the game is anything different from what I first thought. It’s a cooperative game – not typically games I enjoy enough to want in my collection. And I’m not generally overly enamored with deduction games either, though more of those work for me. But trying more cases in Witness has led to a desire to try more and more cases, and more complex ones as well.
But the game has been one of the most divisive of any game in my collection. In spite of trying to limit the audience to those I think would enjoy the game, I’ve witnessed many people for whom a single play was too much. At the same time, the game has been a big hit with others. As a result, I’ve tried to emphasize the nature of the game – a communication game with a strong memory element, leading up to a number of deductions at the end – to anyone who has been interested. That still hasn’t worked perfectly – I’ve not been able to guess accurately who will enjoy the game – but I’ve at least managed to avoid it with some folks.
Witness is a simply but nicely produced game, primarily consisting of books – a rule book, a case book, four player clue books, a question book, and a solution book, plus tokens to indicate who is who. The artwork, based upon the Blake & Mortimer comics, is lovely, and carried out consistently through the materials. Even as someone who had never heard of the series, I’ve found it easy to relate and the stories are engaging and clever.
There are only two disappointments I have with the game. One is that there are too many easy cases. All of the cases listed as easy qualify, of course, but the regular difficulty cases tend to be somewhat too easy as well. This takes away nothing from the harder cases, of course. The other disappointment is an easily solved one: the game comes with only 64 cases. While at one time I would have thought that plenty, now I’m nearly 1/3 of the way through them. Hopefully more cases will be released – maybe even with an emphasis on more difficult cases.
Witness is, in my experience, entirely unique. Because of that, I think it’s hard to judge if someone will like the game without trying it. It’s not hard, on the other hand, to judge if you’ll “dislike” the game; I doubt the game will convert anyone who doesn’t enjoy memory, deduction, or communication games. About the only camp it might convert is those who aren’t generally fond of cooperative games. I generally find such games enjoyable, but not compelling and not games I need in my collection. This is a strong exception. Even if no more cases are released, I expect to hold on to the game long enough to finally forget the cases previously solved.
Summer 2015 GA Report Articles
Reviewed by: Herb Levy (Eagle/Gryphon Games, 1-4 players, ages 8 and up, 45-60 minutes; $39.99; Deluxe Edition $64.99)
Let's start this review by being perfectly frank. I'm a baseball purist. I like the game the way it is played; I still can't get used to the Designated Hitter. So you can imagine my reaction when I heard about a baseball game set in the future ...Read More
Reviewed by: Greg J. Schloesser (Tasty Minstrel Games, 3 to 5 players, ages 13 and up, 120-150 minutes; $69.95)
Generally, I am not fond of economic games, tending to find them fairly dry and business-like. I am a businessman by profession, so playing a game that is about a business strays a bit too close to what I do for a living. I want my ...Read More
Reviewed by Andrea "Liga" Ligabue (Asmodee/Ludonaute, 2 to 6 players, ages 10 and up, less than 60 minutes; $39.99)
The Old West is always fascinating, at least for us Europeans looking at the wide spaces of the US with a mix of awe and astonishment. Gunslingers, Indians, coaches, saloons and shoot-outs are powerful tools in the hands of expert designers. Bang!, Carson City, Dice Town, ...Read More
Imitation is... "...the sincerest form of flattery", at least according to Oscar Wilde. But you know what else imitation is? BORING!
When your "lofty goal" is to copy, as closely as possible, something successful (we're talking about games here but this applies to almost everything), you are doomed to fail. When your new version of something is just about the same as the old version, ...Read More
Reviewed by: Herb Levy (Space Cowboys/Asmodee, 2 to 4 players, ages 14 and up, 60 minutes; $59.99)
Ambition is a powerful force. When you are a human being, it can be the drive that moves you up the corporate ladder or shoots you to the top in political circles. But when you are a demigod with designs on claiming a spot on Mount Olympus, you ...Read More
Reviewed by: Chris Kovac (Z-Man Games,1-2 players, ages 14 and up, 120 minutes; $79.99)
Fields of Arle is a two player game of resource collecting and management by Uwe Rosenberg following his games like Agricola, Le Harve and Caverna in scope and style. The object of the game is to have the most points after nine turns. (more…)
Reviewed by: Herb Levy (Renegade Game Studios/Foxtrot Games, 2 to 4 players, ages 8 and up, 30 minutes; $34.99)
Just when you think you've seen all the possible permutations of tile laying games, you discover something new. In Lanterns: The Harvest Festival, designed by Christopher Chung, tile laying is deftly combined with card play in a game where the setting is China and players are ...Read More
[In our issues, we generally focus on the newest and best games on the market today (when we're not highlighting some great classic game no longer in print). This piece, however, is an exception. James Davis is a big fan of Memoir 44, a well received game of World War II action originally featured in the Summer 2004 issue of GA Report. With over a ...
Reviewed by: Herb Levy (Queen Games, 2 to 4 players, ages 8 and up, 45 minutes; $49.99)
The smell of success is in the air for the player who can concoct the more desirable perfumes and sell them to the illustrious clientele who desire them in the latest game from the design team of Marco Ruskowski and Marcel Sobelbeck: Parfum. (more…)
Reviewed by: Herb Levy (Asmadi Games, 2 to 5 players, ages 14 and up, 45-60 minutes; $59.99)
In the late 19th-early 20th century, the glue that held the masses together, keeping them in touch with the events of the day and each other, were the newspapers. These publications ran the gamut from high toned conveyers of the news to flamboyant and sensational journalism, commonly known ...Read More
Reviewed by: Herb Levy (Griggling Games Inc., 2 to 6 players, ages 13 and up, 90 minutes; $49.95)
For the longest time, there has been a disconnect between wargames and Euro strategy games. Whether the trauma of World War II was simply too much to allow Europeans to revisit such a destructive conflict or differing cultural influences are to account for this, I'll leave to ...Read More
Reviewed by: Herb Levy (R & R Games, 2 to 4 players, ages 14 and up, 25 minutes; $19.95)
Did you ever wonder how rival Mages settle their disputes? Well, it's not by sharing their feelings. In Spellcaster, a new game designed by Aaron Weissblum and Norman Woods, we discover that such disagreements are settled the only way they could be: through magical combat Read More
Reviewed by: Pevans (Quined Games, 2-4 players, ages 12 and up, 60-90 minutes; $59.99)
It’s Earth, Jim, but not as we know it. I first played The Golden Ages, designed by Luigi Ferrini, at Dutch publisher Quined’s stand at Spiel ‘14 and was immediately taken with it. It’s a civilisation development game that takes familiar features and puts them together in a different way – ...Read More
Reviewed by: Joe Huber (Z-Man Games/Hans im Glűck, 2 to 4 players, ages 12 and up, 40-100 minutes; $59.99)
For me, the question of the most consistent publisher is a fairly easy one. Other than the single designer publishers, I’ve found no publisher who finds as consistently interesting designs as Hans im Glück. Whether classic games such as El Grande, Euphrat & Tigris, and Goa, ...Read More
Reviewed by: Joe Huber (Asmodee Editions/Ystari, 4 players, ages 13 and up, 10 minutes; $39.99)
Every year, after Essen, I participate in a few gatherings to play through the new games. Over the course of a few weekends, I’ll typically end up playing 30 or more new games – most of which I’ll never come back to again. I really enjoy playing new (and new-to-me) ...Read More