Menu

GIANTS

Reviewed by Joe Huber

GIANTS (Asmodee Editions/Editions du Matagot, 3 to 5 players, ages 10 and up, 60 minutes; $69.99)

 

Setting up as a new publisher in the boardgame world is a tricky business. It’s certainly more accessible than setting up in some other industries – imagine the cost to set up as a new car manufacturer, for instance – but until a publisher has a selection of games to sell – and a reasonable level of demand for those games – a new publisher faces an uphill battle. To drive that demand, publishers work hard to find new and innovative, but still accessible, designs. When it works – Ystari’s initial offering of Ys (Winter 2005 GA REPORT) and follow-up of Caylus (Winter 2006 GA REPORT) being an ideal example – a publisher gains the flexibility to take chances on more daring designs and the influence to build productive licensing relationships with publishers in other countries.

But far more common is the experience of Matagot. They arrived on the scene in 2006 with the release of Khronos, a well produced game with some supporters but overall a mixed response. This was followed in 2007 by Utopia, which again drew some acclaim for the production values – but the reaction to the game was again mixed, perhaps a little less positive than with Khronos. So the release at Essen of Giants designed by Fabrice Besson in 2008 was not heavily anticipated, perhaps, but still on the radar of Essen attendees.

Those who investigated the game discovered yet another game themed around Easter Island, which might have the greatest ratio of game designs to people of anywhere on Earth. Here players are carving Moai, and then transporting them to the edges of the island, with the most points earned by carrying the largest Moai to the furthest points of the island. This scoring is complemented by that for sculpting and placing headdressesfor the Moai; they come from the other end of the island, and so the scoring is roughly reversed.

Giants is played over a number of rounds, each consisting of five phases. Before the game begins, players receive 2 tribe markers, 1 worker, 1 sorcerer, and 1 chief. In the first phase, a number of Moai are made available for auction. In the second phase, these Moai are bid upon by the players using tribe markers. To claim a Moai, a player must not only make the highest bid, but must also supply enough workers to carve the Moai desired. A single worker can carve a small Moai, two workers can carve a medium Moai, and three workers can carve a large Moai, while a chief can carve any size Moai.

The third phase is where most of the action in the game takes place. Players take turns, executing one action at a time, until all players pass. There are four options for actions. Any person – worker, sorcerer, or chief – may be placed on the board; these pieces will be available for transporting Moai in the next phase. The second option is to execute a sorcerer action – a sorcerer may acquire an additional worker at the village, acquire an additional tribe marker at the sorcerer’s hut, acquire wood in the forest, reserve an Ahu – the spaces where the Moai are to be built, or sculpt a headdress. Another option is to acquire half of a Rongo tablet by displaying a tribe marker. When a full tablet is acquired, a fourth option becomes available – by turning in a complete tablet, the chief may be used for any sorcerer action. Players continue choosing actions, one at a time, until they pass; once all players have passed, this phase is complete

The fourth phase is the transportation phase. One at a time, players move Moai or headdresses; they can be moved using any player’s pieces. When another player’s workers are used, that player receives one victory point for each worker used. If a Moai is moved all the way to the coast, it can be built immediately on a player’s base. Otherwise, a tribe marker must be placed upon it, or another player can claim it in the next round. The same rules apply to headdresses, but they must be brought to a built Moai – perhaps even one completed in the same phase – to avoid the need for a tribe marker.

Finally, in the fifth phase the board is cleaned off for the next round. If any player has placed Moai on all of her bases, then the game is over. Only Moai on bases and headdresses on Moai now score. Headdresses score based upon their location, while Moai scored based upon their size and location. Whoever has earned the most victory points wins.

There are a lot of things to dislike about Giants. First, there are rules issues; the published rules state that 3 victory points are awarded for each complete Rongo tablet, which is far too many; the latest rules provide for no victory points. Personally, I find that 1 victory point is about right – it provides sufficient use for tribe markers, without making the collection of the available Rongo tablets too high a priority. The rules also specify hidden scoring. While there are games where scoring is complex enough to make it difficult to keep track of, here there’s a very limited amount of information that needs be tracked to calculate the exact scores, and further this information needs to be tracked anyway to avoid putting a headdress on the wrong Moai. A variant is offered in the rules to solve this issue, and I would definitely recommend using it. Further, the game tends to be long for what it is. There’s a fix for this noted in the rules, too – hidden in the game preparation is a suggestion of starting each player with two workers, which again I would strongly recommend. But perhaps the biggest problem with the game is that the very nice production is compromised by pieces that don’t fit together effectively. Tribe markers don’t fit securely on either Moai or headdresses, and headdresses don’t fit securely on Moai, making it very easy to knock things over and upset the game state. Adding all of these issues up, Giants has a lot going against it.

However, Giants also manages to make shared delivery work in a way I’ve never seen it done before. I first became attracted to this concept in Lancashire Railways, the earliest game I played which offers an interesting attempt at allowing players to work toward mutually beneficial route building. But the advantage to the player whose routes were utilized was too large, and the series was developed in a way that emphasized other elements of the system. The next game to explore shared delivery in a way I found appealing was Canal Mania (featured in the Fall 2006 GA REPORT) which I greatly enjoyed but still tended to utilize shared delivery as a secondary aspect. In Giants, shared delivery is a key element of the game and, to make it even more interesting, the routes are rebuilt fresh every turn. This mechanism is an amazing discovery, but it also fits very effectively within the remainder of the game. The key is that players are given victory points from the bank, rather than from another player, making the advantage of utilizing other player’s workers greater than the tendency towards greed.

While Giants is not a complex game, it does have a fair number of rules, and as a result tends to take a while to get started. The theme works quite well within the structure of the game, which does help to cut down on rule issues once the game has started. In particular, the slow but certain destruction of the forest, the exceptional (if not fully functional) pieces, and the mechanisms of moving the Moai do a very good job in evoking the theme. The brief history of Easter Island provided in the rules is also very welcome. And with some points awarded for Rongo tablets, there are plenty of viable choices for scoring and thus good choices to make during the game.

Upon first play, Giants was my second favorite of the Essen 2008 releases, behind Le Havre (Winter 2009 GA REPORT). While it hasn’t slipped, other games – Planet Steam (Spring 2009 GA REPORT) in particular – have passed it. I still enjoy the game; I’m just not certain how many more plays it will provide for me. But at the same time, the shared delivery is SO well done that I keep being drawn to the game; I’ve described the game as the one I wanted Age of Steam to be, for this reason. For the reasons enumerated above, it’s hard to recommend the game without reservation. For many, this is a game to try before you buy. But the shared delivery aspect of Giants helps the game overcome its flaws and, if the shared delivery aspect appeals to you, I would definitely recommend it. – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – Joe Huber


 

Have feedback? We’d love to hear from you.


Fall 2009 GA Report Articles

 

Reviewed by Andrea "Liga" Ligabue ALEA IACTA EST (Alea/Rio Grande Games, 2 to 5 players, ages 9 and up, 60 minutes; $39.95) Following the way showed by To Court the King and Kingsburg (Spring 2008 GA REPORT), side by side with Roll Through the Ages (Spring 2009 GA REPORT), Alea Iacta Est, from Bernd Eisenstein and Jeffrey D. Allers, is more than a simple dice ...
Read More
Reviewed by Greg J. Schloesser AUTOMOBILE (Warfrog/Treefrog Games, 3 to 5 players, ages 13 and up, 2 to 3 hours; about $70) While I often bemoan the reuse – over and over again – of similar themes in board game design, I am occasionally impressed by an original theme that I had either previously never considered, or thought would be far too boring a subject ...
Read More
When You're Right, You're Right! By now, it's not news that Dominion has won the prestigious 2009 Spiel des Jahres as Game of the Year. I make it my business to know and play as many new releases as possible so the best (and the brightest) of them can appear in our pages. When I first encountered Dominion, however, I wasn't convinced. My initial experience ...
Read More
(One of the "Holy Grails" of gaming over the last few decades is a brilliant game of adventure set in the exotic locales of the Middle East. Rumors of its resurrection continually circulated and, in fact, a German language reissue of the game did appear in the 1990s. Now, with a new English language edition of this game finally released [and reviewed in this issue], ...
Read More
Reviewed by Joe Huber GIANTS (Asmodee Editions/Editions du Matagot, 3 to 5 players, ages 10 and up, 60 minutes; $69.99) Setting up as a new publisher in the boardgame world is a tricky business. It’s certainly more accessible than setting up in some other industries – imagine the cost to set up as a new car manufacturer, for instance – but until a publisher has ...
Read More
Reviewed by Herb Levy LOOTING LONDON (Gryphon Games, 2 to 5 players, ages 10 and up, 30 minutes; $24.95) London is under attack by criminal elements as no less than five rare treasures have been looted in a single night. But not to worry, the best sleuths (notice the familiar figure on the box cover?) are on the case, attempting to solve these dastardly crimes ...
Read More
Reviewed by Herb Levy MARTIAN FLUXX (Looney Labs, 2-6 players, ages 8 and up, 5-30 minutes; $16) The appropriately named Looney Labs often manages to come up with clever games with a humorous twist. Perhaps its most famous game is Fluxx, a wildly chaotic game of rules making and rules breaking (featured over a decade ago in the Summer 1998 GA REPORT). The game's success ...
Read More
Reviewed by Chris Kovac RED NOVEMBER (Fantasy Flight Games, 2-8 players, ages 12 and up, 1-2 hours; $24.95) Red November is a humorous 2-8 player cooperative designed by Bruno Faidutti and Jeff Contier. This small box game is published by Fantasy Flight games as part of their Silver Line series of light gamer games. This game is set in a world ruled by gnomes who ...
Read More
Reviewed by Herb Levy REVOLUTION! (Steve Jackson Games, 3 to 4 players, ages 13 to adult, 60 minutes; $39.95) Throughout history, we've seen government change happen in different ways. Sometimes, a new leader brings a change through a landslide election. Perhaps the death of a royal ruler causes a change in governance. But sometimes, the political pot boils over as dissatisfied factions gather together and ...
Read More
Reviewed by Herb Levy STEAM: RAILS TO RICHES (Mayfair Games, 3 to 6 players, ages 12 to adult, 90+ minutes; $55) Martin Wallace has established himself as a name to be reckoned with in game design. Perhaps the most lauded game under his byline would be Age of Steam (featured in the Winter 2003 GA REPORT) which, for many aficionados of the genre, sets the ...
Read More
Reviewed by Herb Levy TALES OF THE ARABIAN NIGHTS (Z-Man Games, 2 to 6 players, ages 12 and up, 120+ minutes; $59.99) Some games appear, shine brightly for awhile and then disappear into limbo, never to seen again. In some cases, they remain highly regarded and some even assume the status of a "Holy Grail" as knowledgeable gamers seek to obtain this gaming treasure. Such ...
Read More
Reviewed by Pevans TULIPMANIA 1637 (JKLM Games, 3 to 5 players, ages 10 to adult, 60 minutes; $28) The subject matter of the game is, of course, the first financial bubble—the runaway speculation in tulip bulbs in Holland in 1637, a phenomenon that has been repeated several times in the intervening centuries with other products and in other markets. However, before I get into the ...
Read More
Reviewed by Herb Levy VALDORA (Abacusspiele, 3 to 5 players, ages 10 to adult, 60 minutes; about $60) Exotic locations have long been used as settings for boardgames. But when you add to the locale the possibility of great riches to be found in gems, you've got the premise of Valdora, the latest design from Michael Schacht. Valdora comes with a mounted game board, 78 ...
Read More

If you enjoy games, then Gamers Alliance is right for you!