Menu

CANAL MANIA

Reviewed by Craig Massey

(Ragnar Brothers, 3-5 players, ages teen to adult, about 90 minutes; about $50)

 

The release of a Ragnar Brothers game is a highly anticipated event that comes along once every few years. Anticipation for Canal Mania started building back in the summer and fall of 2005 with information from session reports and sneak previews from the brothers themselves. When Essen 2005 came and went without the game being released, we were left waiting and wondering about the eventual appearance. Almost eight months later, the game arrived on what many felt were the slowest boats to cross the Atlantic since the Mayflower.

So now that the game is out, what have the brothers Ragnar given us? Well, the first thing owners of previous Ragnar Brothers games will notice is the top-notch production job. Gone are the days when you could wipe your cheese puff-stained fingers on the corner of a RB game board when no one was looking. The tea towel board that was a Ragnar Brothers trademark has been replaced in Canal Mania with a full color, mounted map board of England showing the cities and towns of England, each in one of six colors. The remaining spaces are divided up into hexes of two different flavors: easy and difficult terrain. The rest of the bits – player tiles, player markers (boats), cards of three varieties (resources, contracts, and engineers) as well as the box and rules have also been given the deluxe treatment providing a polished feel normally associated with the larger German game companies.

Enough about the looks, how does the game play? The theme is one of building the canal system in late 18th and early 19th century England. Not a theme I have ever really thought about, but one which has not previously been tackled by game designers. Players are tasked with the goal of collecting resource cards of four types and using them to construct canal routes between the cities and towns of England. Building these routes fulfills specific contracts historically provided by parliament. Once built, the routes are then used for the delivery of goods. Points are scored based on completed routes as well as delivery of said goods along those routes. Players get tiles pieces and boats in their color as well as randomly drawing one of five engineer cards and are off and running.

Player turns are divided into three actions. First, players have the option to claim a contract, enlist a different engineer, or clear the available resource cards for a fresh tableau. A player without a contract must select one from the available contracts. At any point and time, a player may have a maximum of two contracts. Contracts specify the two cities and/or towns to be linked as well as a contract value. This represents the maximum amount of tiles that may be laid to connect these endpoints.

If a player has a contract, they could choose to swap engineers with another player. Each engineer provides the player with a unique ability. Four engineers help players with the construction of canals. The fifth engineer allows players to build up their resources faster. If swapping engineers doesn’t fit a player’s master plan that turn, the player can get a fresh set of resource cards for use during the second action.

After completing one of the above, the player moves onto the second action. Here the player has two options – drawing resource cards or building canal segments. Drawing cards allows a player to select up to three of five available cards. Resource cards come in five different flavors – one for each type of canal piece as well as a wild card. Drawing cards also brings goods onto the board for eventual delivery. Some cards have goods symbols on them. When these are drawn, players place two goods cubes onto the board in cities or towns of a matching color. If a player has accumulated sufficient cards, building is an option.

Building is a simple matter of playing cards to match the types of pieces needed to connect the cities and towns required for a contract. There are a few restrictions on building. First, players may never play the same canal piece in consecutive hexes. Second, the terrain on the map affects which types of pieces can be played. Two types of canal pieces can be built in simple terrain and the other two types of pieces can be built in the difficult terrain. Playing tiles in difficult terrain requires more cards. If during building a player has completed a route, points are scored based on the type of tiles used to complete the route. Simple terrain pieces score zero or one point each. Difficult terrain pieces score two or three points each.canalmania2

The last action after a player has drawn cards or built is to deliver a goods cube. If the player has access to goods in towns or cities, one goods cube may be delivered along completed canal sections. Goods can travel along as many segments as desired as long as the cube does not visit a city or town of the same color more than once. The final segment in the delivery must be a segment owned by the delivery player. Cities and towns are all one of six different colors which means at most a cube may visit six different towns or cities. Points are scored for each city or town visited along the route for all players whose routes are used. Players have one final option available to them during each of their three actions. They may always forgo an action in order to draw a random card from the deck.

The game continues until a prescribed score is surpassed (this score changes depending on the number of players) or until the final contracts become available. At that point, players have two final turns and then all remaining goods on the board are delivered. A final scoring bonus is awarded to the player with the most completed contracts and huzzahs and pats on the back are given to the player with the highest score.

The game is on par with Age of Steam (Winter 2003 GA REPORT) in weight and complexity as well. Players have a limited range of interesting choices. In the games I played, it always seemed that I wanted to do one more thing and I was incrementally building up to something larger even though the game offers more in the way of a tactical rather than a strategic challenge. There is some scope to interfere with your opponents, but player interaction is largely limited. Players are racing to complete contacts and claim more contracts that fit best with their existing routes, but aside from grabbing the occasional goods cube for delivery coveted by your opponent, there is no opportunity to really go after anyone.

The game does reward experience. My first game saw everyone floundering around with a disjointed network of canals that provided little synergy. The second time through the game things clicked though offering a richer and less random experience. Luck plays a small role in the form of your card drawing choice and placement of goods cubes. Often you can feel like there is nothing useful to draw at all, but there are things you can do to ameliorate luck’s affects. For example, often players will avoid using their first action to clear the tableau. While this certainly isn’t terribly efficient, it does help. Also, players should judiciously swap engineers to make the most of the cards they do have and make more efficient use of the cards they hold.

Canal Mania fits into the broader category of “train” games. Yes, the theme has one digging ditches for water travel, but ultimately it is about completing a network of routes and delivery goods along those routes – not unlike Age of Steam, Railway Rivals (Fall 1990 GA REPORT) or even Ticket To Ride (Spring 2004 GA REPORT). Those who enjoy “train” games will no doubt see this resemblance as well and be quite happy with Canal Mania. Those looking to avoid yet another game about trains will enjoy this too because the theme definitely fits the game and is different enough from the “train” game genre.

In the end, Canal Mania is easily one of my favorite games for 2006. The theme supports the mechanics and game play and the options and decisions available have remained interesting and fresh over several games. I have been left wondering after each game “if only….,” which is a very good sign. Those favoring train games will definitely find much to like as an alternative to the usual fair and those looking for something a little meatier should find enough in this latest offering from Ragnar Brothers. – – – – – – – Craig Massey


 

Have feedback? We’d love to hear from you.


Fall 2006 GA Report Articles

 

Reviewed by Herb Levy (Out of the Box Games, 4 players, ages 12 and up, 30-40 minutes; $14.99) When it comes to trick-taking games, Bridge is undoubtedly king of the castle. There are newspaper columns specializing in it, several high profile celebrities (Omar Sharif for example) devoted to it and thousands of card players spending hours on it. Despite this, the game remains a mystery ...
Read More
Reviewed by Craig Massey (Ragnar Brothers, 3-5 players, ages teen to adult, about 90 minutes; about $50) The release of a Ragnar Brothers game is a highly anticipated event that comes along once every few years. Anticipation for Canal Mania started building back in the summer and fall of 2005 with information from session reports and sneak previews from the brothers themselves. When Essen 2005 ...
Read More
Reviewed by Herb Levy (Immortal Eyes/Winning Moves Games, 2-4 players, ages teen to adult, 90+ minutes; $40.95) Scientists theorize that, in the beginning, the Earth consisted of one large land mass that, over time, broke apart to create the continents we know today. In Conquest of Pangea, this idea is the crux of the gameplay as the super-continent of Pangea starts to split. It is ...
Read More
Blackjack I've been to Las Vegas and I have to say that it strikes me as a fantasy land, truly as Disney World for adults. There's glitz and glamour all along the Vegas strip. I enjoy the top entertainment there and the whole atmosphere, from the pyramid marking the Luxor to the movie set-like setting of New York, New York to the gorgeous Bellagio and ...
Read More
[In this issue of GA REPORT, we welcome first time contributor Joe Huber. Joe is a well known gamer and he writes: "I grew up playing Acquire and Civilization, and still enjoy both games today - if few of the wargames I also played back then. In 1995, I got back into gaming, discovering both German games (particularly Settlers of Catan and Auf Achse), ...
Read More
Reviewed by Herb Levy (Pywacket LLC, 2 to 6 players, ages 8 to adult, about 30-60 minutes; $24.99, Deluxe Edition $29.99) Word search puzzles have been quite popular over the last few years and building a board game upon that premise is nothing new. For example, Pressman issued a game, featured in the Spring 1988 issue of GA REPORT, called Wordsearch. Fast forward almost 20 ...
Read More
Reviewed by Herb Levy (Winning Moves, 3-5 players, ages teen to adult, 35-45 minutes; $25.95 ) Leonardo Da Vinci was a true genius, an intellect who excelled in many fields. Arguably his most famous contribution to the world is his masterpiece, the Mona Lisa, a painting that has captured the imagination of art lovers the world over for centuries. Part of the appeal comes from ...
Read More
Reviewed by Herb Levy (Immortal Eyes/Winning Moves Games, 2 players, ages teen to adult, 30 minutes; $23.95) Pecking Order, the first release from the Immortal Eyes imprint launched by Winning Moves, is a Richard Garfield design combining simplicity with a strong undercurrent of bluff and strategy. Pecking Order comes with a mounted board and two identical decks of cards. Each deck consists of 12 numbered ...
Read More
Reviewed by Chris Kovac (Queen, 2-4 players, ages 8 and up, 30 minutes; $24.95 ) Robber Knights is one of the small box games released after Nuremburg earlier this year and is a tile laying strategy game for 2-4 players designed by Rudiger Dorn, probably best known for Goa (Summer 2004 GA REPORT) and Louis XIV (Summer 2005 GA REPORT). The object of the game ...
Read More
[With this issue, we welcome new contributor Frank Hamrick. Frank says: My Grandmother taught me Monopoly when I was 7 years old and I became an addict! I played every game I could find from Monopoly to Parcheesi, Sorry, Commandos, and Dig. By the time I was in High School I decided that the world needed a good war game and started designing my ...
Read More
Reviewed by Herb Levy (Immortal Eyes/Winning Moves Games, 2-4 players, ages teen to adult, 45+ minutes; $30.95) Exploring a New World is always an exciting prospect. In Terra Nova. the third release from the Immortal Eyes imprint launched by Winning Moves, that sense of exploration is captured as two to four players compete to carve out their own niches in this beautifully produced game. Terra ...
Read More
Reviewed by Pevans (Hans im Glück/Rio Grande Games, 2-4 players, ages 10 and up, 60 minutes; $32.95) Well, it’s just won the Spiel des Jahres (Game of the Year) in Germany and there’s been quite a buzz about Thurn und Taxis since it first appeared: let’s see if it lives up to its reputation. Interestingly, the game’s author is given as Karen and Andreas Seyfarth ...
Read More
Why Everyone Should Visit Essen (at least once) by Ben Baldanza A few years ago, I was in a meeting with some German businessmen. During small talk, I mentioned that I would be visiting their country in mid October. Happily, they asked where I would be going, and when I said "Essen" they had a most quizzical look. One finally said what they all were ...
Read More

If you enjoy games, then Gamers Alliance is right for you!